Week 7 Discussion 1
Discuss the steps required to submit research to a professional journal, and what you feel will be the biggest obstacle? Why?
Submitting research to a professional journal involves several steps, each crucial for ensuring the quality and readiness of the manuscript for publication. The following are the typical steps required to submit research to a professional journal:
- Manuscript preparation: The first step involves preparing the manuscript according to the journal’s guidelines and formatting requirements. This includes organizing the manuscript into sections such as introduction, methods, results, discussion, and references, as well as ensuring clarity, coherence, and adherence to the journal’s style and word count limitations.
- Selecting a journal: Researchers must identify suitable journals that align with the scope and focus of their research topic. Factors to consider include the journal’s readership, impact factor, publication frequency, acceptance rates, and editorial policies. It is essential to choose a reputable journal with a strong track record of publishing high-quality research in the relevant field.
- Pre-submission inquiries (optional): Some journals offer the option of submitting pre-submission inquiries to assess the suitability of the manuscript for the journal and receive feedback from the editors before submitting the full manuscript. This step can help researchers gauge the potential interest of the journal in their research and address any concerns or questions from the editors upfront.
- Manuscript submission: Once the manuscript is prepared according to the journal’s guidelines, researchers can submit it through the journal’s online submission system. The submission process typically involves uploading the manuscript file, completing a submission form with author information and manuscript details, and sometimes providing a cover letter or other supplementary materials.
- Peer review process: After submission, the manuscript undergoes a peer review process, where it is evaluated by experts in the field who assess its originality, methodological rigor, significance, and clarity. The peer reviewers provide constructive feedback and recommendations for revisions, which the authors must address before the manuscript can be accepted for publication.
- Revision and resubmission: Authors are usually given a specified timeframe to revise their manuscript based on the feedback from peer reviewers and editors. This may involve making revisions to the text, addressing reviewer comments, clarifying methodology or results, and providing additional evidence or analyses as needed.
- Acceptance and publication: If the revised manuscript meets the journal’s standards and receives approval from the editor, it will be accepted for publication. The manuscript then undergoes copyediting, typesetting, and proofreading before being published in the journal’s print or online edition.
The biggest obstacle in submitting research to a professional journal is often the peer review process. Peer reviewers may provide extensive feedback and critiques of the manuscript, which can be challenging for authors to address, especially if there are conflicting opinions or requests for major revisions. Moreover, the peer review process can be time-consuming, with multiple rounds of revisions and resubmissions required before the manuscript is finally accepted for publication. Additionally, navigating the peer review process requires patience, resilience, and the ability to incorporate constructive feedback while maintaining the integrity and originality of the research.