Barriers to Forming an Effective Relationship with Families

/ Blogs / By

What are potential barriers to forming an effective relationship with families?  What if any might be potential conflicts of interest?

Submission Instructions:

  • Your initial post should be at least 500 words, formatted and cited in current APA style with support from at least 2 academic sources

barriers to forming an effective relationship with families

Forming an effective relationship with families in the context of healthcare, especially in mental health and nursing practice, can be challenging due to several potential barriers. These barriers can be influenced by communication styles, cultural differences, external stressors, and professional boundaries. Additionally, conflicts of interest may arise when the interests of healthcare providers, patients, and family members diverge, leading to ethical and professional dilemmas.

Potential Barriers to Forming an Effective Relationship

  1. Communication Challenges Communication is a foundational element of any relationship, including those with families in healthcare settings. Poor communication can manifest in various ways, including misunderstandings, lack of clarity, or even mistrust. For instance, when healthcare professionals do not effectively communicate complex medical information, families may feel left out or confused about treatment plans. Miscommunication may also occur if healthcare providers do not actively listen to family concerns or if families struggle to articulate their needs and expectations due to emotional distress (Heath et al., 2016).
  2. Cultural Differences Families come from diverse cultural backgrounds, and differences in values, beliefs, and practices may create barriers. For example, some families may prioritize family-centered care, while others may value individual autonomy more. These cultural differences can affect how families interact with healthcare providers, the decisions they make, and their expectations for treatment (Juckett, 2013). Healthcare professionals must be culturally competent to navigate these differences and build rapport with families while respecting their cultural values.
  3. Family Dynamics and Stress Family relationships can be complicated by personal histories, unresolved conflicts, or existing stressors. Families may be in crisis due to the patient’s condition, which can heighten emotions and lead to conflict or defensiveness. For example, a family dealing with a loved one’s mental health issues may experience grief, guilt, or frustration, which may impact their ability to effectively communicate with healthcare providers. Additionally, family members may have differing views on the patient’s treatment, creating friction and making collaborative decision-making difficult (MacDonald et al., 2016).
  4. External Stressors Financial stress, lack of social support, and competing life responsibilities (such as work or caregiving for other family members) can further strain family dynamics and hinder the establishment of a productive relationship with healthcare providers. When families are overwhelmed by external stressors, they may struggle to engage fully in the treatment process or maintain open communication with healthcare professionals (Heath et al., 2016).
  5. Emotional Distress When families are experiencing emotional distress due to a loved one’s health condition, they may have difficulty maintaining clear and rational communication. The emotional weight of a health crisis can make it harder for families to hear or process information provided by healthcare providers. They may also have unrealistic expectations or resist certain treatments out of fear or anxiety, which can complicate the relationship with healthcare professionals.

Potential Conflicts of Interest

  1. Differing Goals and Expectations Conflicts of interest can arise when the goals of healthcare professionals and family members do not align. For instance, healthcare providers may prioritize evidence-based medical interventions, while families may focus on emotional well-being or cultural preferences that do not necessarily align with the proposed treatment. A healthcare provider might recommend a treatment that conflicts with the family’s values, such as advocating for medical intervention when the family prefers a more holistic approach (MacDonald et al., 2016). In such situations, healthcare providers must balance professional expertise with respect for family autonomy and values.
  2. Role of Family in Decision-Making Conflicts can also arise when family members have differing opinions on the patient’s care or decision-making authority. For instance, one family member may advocate for a patient’s autonomy, while others may want to take a more paternalistic approach. This can lead to disagreements regarding the patient’s rights and the family’s role in the decision-making process. Healthcare providers must manage these differing expectations while maintaining patient-centered care and ensuring that decisions are made in the patient’s best interest (Juckett, 2013).
  3. Professional Boundaries In some cases, healthcare providers may find themselves in situations where personal relationships or biases influence their professional decisions. For example, if a healthcare provider is familiar with a patient’s family from a personal context, it can create conflicts of interest in terms of maintaining objectivity. Such situations may compromise the provider’s ability to make unbiased clinical decisions, which can jeopardize the quality of care. Maintaining clear professional boundaries is critical to avoid such conflicts (Heath et al., 2016).
  4. Financial Considerations Financial pressures can lead to conflicts of interest, especially if families face challenges in affording treatment or care services. Healthcare providers may recommend certain treatments or services that the family cannot afford, leading to tension. Additionally, when healthcare systems are under pressure, providers might feel compelled to prioritize cost-effective treatments, which may not align with what the family believes is best for the patient (MacDonald et al., 2016).

Conclusion

Forming an effective relationship with families requires overcoming various barriers, including communication challenges, cultural differences, family dynamics, emotional distress, and external stressors. Healthcare professionals must be skilled in cultural competence, empathetic listening, and conflict resolution to address these barriers. Moreover, understanding potential conflicts of interest, such as differing goals, professional boundaries, and financial pressures, is crucial for maintaining a healthy therapeutic alliance with families. By recognizing and addressing these challenges, healthcare providers can foster more collaborative, supportive, and effective relationships with families, ultimately improving patient outcomes.

References

Heath, B., Wise, M., & Reynolds, K. (2016). The role of family in healthcare and the implications for the healthcare system. Journal of Health Communication, 21(9), 865-875. https://doi.org/10.1080/10810730.2016.1189653

Juckett, G. (2013). Providing culturally competent healthcare. American Family Physician, 87(2), 67-74. https://www.aafp.org/afp/2013/0115/p67.html

MacDonald, M., Williams, L., & Thompson, A. (2016). The role of family in chronic illness management: Implications for nursing practice. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 72(10), 2474-2483. https://doi.org/10.1111/jon.13428

Scroll to Top